You are viewing dsjohndrow's blog MyFitnessPal is a 100% Free Calorie Counter and Diet Plan

Challenges, Facts, Fiction and Fallacy

Let me start by apologizing for the screwing up of a near perfect alliteration in my title. As weight losers, humans, athletes and wannabe athletes, we face many decisions during our journey. Some of those decisions you would think would be no-brainers, however; based on the staggering amount of controversial health and fitness posts in cyberspace, that is not at all the case.

Excuse me a moment while I put on my own guru hat.

Challenges: There are dozens of them every day. What do we eat? When should we eat? What should we do if we blow it? How should we train? How much cardio? How much strength training? How many long runs? Are these running shoes cute? What underwear chafes less? Do avocados make you fart?

There seems to be science to back up every position, which makes getting it right, overwhelming.

The best approach to managing challenges is to have a plan. A plan needs to have a goal such as losing 20 pounds, training to finish a 5K in under 30 minutes, or to bench press a baby elephant - that sort of thing. Then the plan needs bite size steps. No matter what you are doing, if you can't make it a priority, it will continue to challenge you, and probably defeat you too. Make a schedule to reach your goal and adjust it as needed.

It's OK to switch your long run day to one that is sunny instead of a blizzard-ing.

Facts: Fact just are. They are true and never predicated on theory. Most of our science seems to be based on the logical outcome of selected facts. That is junk science. (seems to work for politics and religion too) Real science takes into consideration, all the facts. An anecdotal outcome such as I drank 10 cups of water and only peed out 6 does not specifically mean that you retained 4 cups of water. The point is there are other ways for the water to escape the body. And when it comes to water, there are many sources unless you are only eating celery powder. Oh - and here's a tip: don't drink out of the same cup you peed in.

Do you want facts? Use a tape measure, a measuring cup and a food scale.

The bottom line is that each one of us is metabolically different, and that is a fact. Some are prone to gain weight depending on their protein/carbohydrate /fat intake ratio. Some are sensitive to sodium, others are not. Some have a thyroid problem, and others have a sugar addiction; we are all different.

Worse than junk science is outcome based logic which is not backed by facts. There are a lot of hypotheses regarding calories, weight loss, marathon training and other health related issues. Although the basic math of calories in/calories out holds an overall truth, it is pretty much fiction because all calories are not created equally. Caloric labels, treadmill displays, and Garmin HRMs are all educated guesses which can be used as a guide. They are pure fiction.

The fiction is based on how caloric content is measured. Basically the testers incinerate the food, but that is not exactly how it happens in a your body. At least one study showed that people who ate the exact same amount of calories of salmon vs beef, showed slightly greater weight loss. I can attest to the fact that it is much easier to burn 80/20 burgers than it is a piece of salmon when grilling.

The bottom line, it does matter what types of food you eat.

When it comes to training and running, most plans are based on some sort of mathematical progression and not on any actual physiological evidence, except that if you have an injury, you pushed it too hard.

Be very skeptical if instant results, magic pill diets and train for 3 days a week marathon training plans. For every person that could possibly achieve those results, there are thousands who cannot.

I am not even convinced that a 1 or 2 pound a week weight loss number is ideal. The truth is no matter what plan you use, what diet, what training you force yourself to do, you will gain back 73% of what you lost for one reason, and one reason alone: You stopped doing what was working.

Did I say you need to adjust your plan to meet your goal?

I lost 30 pounds in 3 months by adding a little exercise (90 minutes a week) and cutting calories. I actually had a couple of 4+ pound loss weeks. I have never gained it back in 2 years time.

The point is this, we need to choose a lifestyle of good foods and regular, and increasing cardio with a mix of solid strength training.

Which brings me to my first point. The challenge is setting a goal with obtainable steps.

Thank you for commenting and voting!

The Kickstarter video for my new book is just around the corner. Follow the progress on


103 votes + -


tonybalony01 wrote 109 months ago:
Great advice, as usual.
Leahbcc wrote 109 months ago:
Thank you for this
piscesy2k wrote 109 months ago:
Agree with you completely!
SmartFunGorgeous wrote 109 months ago:
This is well done, except, as a technicality, I disagree with you on one point. You mentioned that treadmills, HMRs, and caloric labels are educated guesses, and then equated that to pure fiction. That is quite an exaggeration! For example, an educated guess would be to say an apple has approximately 70 calories, while pure fiction would be to say that an apple will make you burp the ABCs backwards while turning you into a tree frog.

geekgirl_2012 wrote 109 months ago:
I agree! :)
hollyrunner wrote 109 months ago:
Great blog!! So true why people gain the weight back...they stop doing what worked!!
eliz_in_pink wrote 109 months ago:
Do avacados make you fart!? LOL!
Elbee1 wrote 109 months ago:
Thank you for this. More motivation for me!
michie27 wrote 109 months ago:
Great post!!
odditblue wrote 109 months ago:
Exactly. Each person will be completely different too. It is not unlocking one key thing that will lead to better health and physical fitness, but a combination of many different things. We are each as individual as our own fingerprints. What works for some won't work for others. And getting rid of the superstitions and fodder thrown at us by the gimmick selling industries living to make a dollar off of the desperate is half of the battle. Thanks for the post. Makes sense. Now if I can just keep it in my head.... :)
Navotc wrote 109 months ago:
Great thoughts, David! Thank you!
turkeyhunter60 wrote 109 months ago:
I love quacamole. Great Blog, thanks.
MaryRegs wrote 109 months ago: always
Denjo060 wrote 109 months ago:
very insightful thanks for another educational post
msbarbiq wrote 109 months ago:
Thank you, awesome, love it!
dwendling63 wrote 109 months ago:
Excellent blog. Thank You for your insightfulness. 2 years ago I was on the same path I am on now. I remember beginning at my exercise journey with walking to the corner of my street and back...then around the block around 4 blocks....3 miles...5 miles...7 miles. Funny how the steps become lighter and the urge to be outdoors is stronger. Then after loosing 40 lbs... I had failing health. Had 2 surgeries back to back within 6 months and gained 40 back through the recovery process. Now I am back to 3 mile walks again it will be 5...and so forth. Moving forward and this time it is easier and more fun...because I recruit others to go with me! LOL!
carolstartingover wrote 109 months ago:
i don't know why my fat sticks to me , I think I sleep too much because of Arthritis pain. So, I make a commitment. Get up at a reasonable time and get no more than 9.5 hours a night. Sounds like a lot, but I also have Fibromylagia which makes me feel good at night and like I never slept in the morning. No Lyrica for me, causes weight gain. That's all I need is a drug which manipulates my efforts. I think Mom put it best when she said to me "Do the best you can with what you have." Than can apply to many things. I don't want to work because I worked for 33 years and retired early to take care of my late husband with MD. He asked me not to work again. He said, " you have worked 2 jobs for the last 20 years and most women would have walked away'. Still, I want to do something meaningful. Thanks for listening. Your blogs are honest but funny too.
joleenl wrote 109 months ago:
Good sound advice!

Add Comment

Commenting as anonymous user

About Me
8a45210ee073b05f7e6aa06c1984583b33cb thumb
About MyFitnessPal
Join MyFitnessPal today and lose weight the healthy way. Get your own 100% free diet blog and calorie counter. Put away your credit card - you'll never pay a cent."

join now for free