You are viewing Azdak's blog MyFitnessPal is a 100% Free Calorie Counter and Diet Plan

Fasted Cardio Does NOT Enhance Fat Loss

"Fasted cardio"--i.e. performing cardiovascular exercise early in the morning on an empty stomach-- is often touted as an effective weight loss strategy. I am not sure exactly when this idea originated, but it is especially popular with bodybuilders and some personal trainers. 

On the surface, the theory seems to "make sense"--in a fasted state, blood sugar levels are lower, stored muscle glycogen tends to be lower, and you have to get your energy from somewhere, so--voila!--you tap directly into those love handles.

However, like many "common sense" recommendations for exercise and weight loss, the efficacy of "fasted cardio" is not supported by science and research.

The first reason is that, as I have stated numerous times, exercise metabolism does not exist in a vacuum. The acute changes that occur in your body in response to exercise represent only a small fraction of daily metabolism. They are not permanent and they are affected by what happens in the other 23 hours of the day. 

Research has clearly shown that the amount or percentage of fat burned during an exercise session affects fat oxidation the rest of the day. In other words, if you burn more fat during a workout, you burn less the rest of the day and vice versa (assuming equal daily calorie intake). After 24 hours, there is no difference in total fat oxidation between individuals who burned more fat during a workout and those who burned more carbohydrate. 

That alone is enough to dismiss any claimed benefits of "fasted cardio" (and the idea that "cardio burns muscle" as well).

However, if we look at the "micro" level, there is little evidence of increased fat burning as well.

Proponents of fasted cardio claim that ingestion of carbohydrates prior to exercise reduces the entry of fatty acids into the mitochondria (where fat is oxidized) and increased insulin results in less breakdown of fatty acids (lipolysis) from the tissues.

However, at least two studies have shown that, even though lipolysis was suppressed 22% after carbohydrate ingestion, there was no difference in fat oxdiation compared to those exercising in a "fasted state".

Another issue is the source of the fatty acids used during exercise. Muscle cells store droplets of lipids, called intramuscular triglycerides (IMTG). While stored adipose tissue may be "mobilized" during exercise, it is the IMTG that provide the majority of the fat that is actually used--up to 80% in trained individuals. 

What that means is that during exercise, even in a fasted state, the body uses already-available stored fat in the muscles as the primary source of fat, NOT subcutaneous stored body fat.  Body fat stores are affected primarily by daily energy balance. 

What the research literature and science DOES support that, indirectly, exercising in a fasted state can impair fat loss, not facilitate it. Studies on preexercise feedings show that performance is impaired--especially for higher-intensity exercise--when one is in a hypoglycemic state. Lower intensity often means fewer calories burned, both during and after a workout. 

Other studies have suggested that ingesting a mixed carbohydrate/protein beverage before exercise results in a higher post-exercise oxygen consumption--after both low-intensity and high-intensity workouts. 

Despite the persistent popularity of "fasted cardio", the evidence clearly shows that it is not the best strategy, either for fat loss or training quality.  

Now, there are many people who prefer exercising in a fasted state and feel that it improves their performance. Let's look at some of the possible reasons: 

1. Many people say food makes them nauseous. This can be a legitimate reason, but it has nothing to do with the topic of "fat burning" or performance. It is always brought up in the discussion, but it is really irrelevant. I will say that there might be some disagreement about what constitutes "pre exercise feeding". We're not talking about a Grand Slam breakfast--a snack or replacement beverage of 100-200 calories is the "feeding".

2. Typical workouts are not that long or high in duration. Most of the studies I have read that study the effects of "fasted vs fed" feature workouts that are 60-120 min in length.  The average 30-45 min morning workout is likely not long enough or hard enough to really tax your energy stores. So, one is not likely to see much of an effect one way or another. 

3. Hard to prove a negative. If someone always exercises in a fasted state, they may not know what they are missing.

Especially based on #2, it is probably not that important who prefers to exercise in a fasted state to change their routine.

However, people should not exercise in a fasted state out of the misguided idea that it is better for fat loss.  

 

3 votes + -

6 comments:

gawleyt wrote 68 months ago:
Hey can you link me the research articles, i agree with your stance just id like to see the research :)
TaoGnosis wrote 67 months ago:
"... I am not sure exactly when this idea originated, but it is especially popular with bodybuilders and some personal trainers."

Just for chuckles (because, really, I agree with you)I'd say they're STILL trying to prove it.

Journal Reference:
Javier T. Gonzalez, Rachel C. Veasey, Penny L. S. Rumbold, Emma J. Stevenson. Breakfast and exercise contingently affect postprandial metabolism and energy balance in physically active males.
British Journal of Nutrition, 2013;
1 DOI: 10.1017/S0007114512005582

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/01/130124091425.htm
guyjeb wrote 62 months ago:
"What the research literature and science DOES support that, indirectly, exercising in a fasted state can impair fat loss, not facilitate it. Studies on preexercise feedings show that performance is impaired--especially for higher-intensity exercise--when one is in a hypoglycemic state. Lower intensity often means fewer calories burned, both during and after a workout. "

"However, people should not exercise in a fasted state out of the misguided idea that it is better for fat loss. "


And not a Single "Link" Was given this day.


Nice blog post, but could really use some References. Without it, your post is still just opinion.
Anonymous wrote 61 months ago:
Thanks for literally nothing.
Anonymous wrote 60 months ago:
Cite a few references when you write stuff like this or you just like you're just crying about not liking the science.

Pointless clickbait.
Anonymous wrote 60 months ago:
As a fat loss strategy, it may be beneficial to stretch the fasted state beyond the exercise event. Is your goal to burn fat during exercise or to burn fat as part of a larger fat loss goal? Hormonal responses, induced by different eating/exercise patterns, that propagate beyond their initiating event are important factors to consider.

Below is the abstract of a study I found interesting.(link at bottom for full study)

Glycogen shortage during fasting triggers liver–brain–adipose neurocircuitry to facilitate fat utilization
During fasting, animals maintain their energy balance by shifting their energy source from carbohydrates to triglycerides. However, the trigger for this switch has not yet been entirely elucidated. Here we show that a selective hepatic vagotomy slows the speed of fat consumption by attenuating sympathetic nerve-mediated lipolysis in adipose tissue. Hepatic glycogen pre-loading by the adenoviral overexpression of glycogen synthase or the transcription factor TFE3 abolished this liver–brain–adipose axis activation. Moreover, the blockade of glycogenolysis through the knockdown of the glycogen phosphorylase gene and the resulting elevation in the glycogen content abolished the lipolytic signal from the liver, indicating that glycogen is the key to triggering this neurocircuitry. These results demonstrate that liver glycogen shortage activates a liver–brain–adipose neural axis that has an important role in switching the fuel source from glycogen to triglycerides under prolonged fasting conditions.

http://www.nature.com/ncomms/2013/130813/ncomms3316/full/ncomms3316.html

Add Comment

Commenting as anonymous user

About Me
740bba0136deda1525d2a5ca914f115c9d5f thumb
Tools
Archives
About MyFitnessPal
Join MyFitnessPal today and lose weight the healthy way. Get your own 100% free diet blog and calorie counter. Put away your credit card - you'll never pay a cent."

join now for free