Message Boards » Fitness and Exercise

TOPIC: Anyone using FitBit with a stationary bike?

 
May 3, 2012 2:54 PM
I rode my bike indoors today after buying a bike trainer. FitBit did not seem to care. :(

Anyone else tried stationary bike riding with a FitBit? I wear my FitBit all the time and would like to keep it on while riding - unless it doesn't do any good. I can always log it in manually.

Thanks!


Created by MyFitnessPal.com - Free Weight Loss Tools
May 3, 2012 2:59 PM
I have seen that some people put it on their sock while riding... I personally have not tried that because I do the start/stop timer on my fitbit and manually log it in later.
  19364215
May 3, 2012 4:21 PM
QUOTE:

I have seen that some people put it on their sock while riding... I personally have not tried that because I do the start/stop timer on my fitbit and manually log it in later.


Thanks! I'll try my sock and see what happens. I had it on my hip as usual.
August 21, 2012 6:51 AM
I keep it in my pocket and find it tracks close enough, my leg is still moving up and down. Working out without pockets today so I'm wearing it in my sock, I'll let you know how that fairs.
  13949925
August 21, 2012 6:58 AM
It's on my body but it's not tracking steps because, well, I'm not taking any. I track my calories with my HRM and create a fitness log on Fitbit.

I would imagine that trying to track calories by having it on my sock while cycling would result in a very inaccurate burn record.
  14267959
August 21, 2012 8:25 AM
Ok, sitting here in a puddle of sweat after doing 60 minutes on a spin bike plus a 5 minute cool down using a HRM connected to the bikes computer while wearing the fitbit on my right sock. Here are the results.

Calories Burned:
Bike: 1900
Fitbit: 1950

Total Steps/RPM
Bike: 5525 ( Averaged by myself, doing 85 RPM average for 65 minutes in order to maintain my fat burning zone of 124 BPM)
Fitbit: 5582 (Actual Reading)

Miles
Bike: 21.4
Fitbit: 2.86

Stairs:
Bike: N/A
Fitbit: 0

Flower:
Bike: Yeah Right
Fitbit: Huuuuge

So, in my humble opinion, I find the Fitbit to be very accurate in every aspect but one. This being said it is a pedometer not a cycleometer????...lol...so if I was walking the mileage would probably be very accurate.

There is nothing out there that is going to be 100% accurate but as far as losing weight is concerned the accuracy of the fitbit is more than precise enough for me to feel confident in tracking most of my exercise.

Note: Have used the fitbit on multiple ellipticals, treadmills, now a bike, and have found it to be quite accurate on all.
Standard MO is to wear it on my hip or front pocket, but nice to see the sock also functions well.

Hope this helps.
  13949925
August 31, 2012 11:54 AM
Thanks so much for listing your data. My fitbit will arrive today so I am looking forward to hitting the gym with it. Sounds like I'll go with the sock since about half of my gym time is bike.
  3453614
July 21, 2014 12:17 PM
Tried this on my exercise bike today for 10 mins at a gentle pace. I took the tracker out of the wrist strap of my flex and placed in into the sock of my right foot.

The bike reported a calorie burn of 36.8
Fitbit reported 54 calories

Now my bike isn't anything special (v-fit folding magnetic exercise bike) so is it possible that the bike is underestimating the calorie burn?
  1881577
August 5, 2014 6:40 AM
i have a turbo trainer and using the fitbit in my sock, it says i burnt 500 calories in 30 mins or moderate cycling, not sure thats true - but would be good!

Today - i put the fit bit on my thigh (on cycle shorts) and says i burnt 280 - i would say the 280 is more accurate :)
August 5, 2014 7:33 AM
The Fitbit's calorie estimate is going to be junk unless you wear it where it's designed to be worn, for an activity it's designed to track (cycling isn't one). If you prefer to see it yourself, wear yours where you're supposed to wear it, walk around the block, note the calorie estimate. Then move it to your shoe or thigh and do it again. Your second calorie estimate will be double or more the first one. You didn't burn any more calories, you just tricked your Fitbit into thinking you're moving more vigorously than you are.

Reply

Message Boards » Fitness and Exercise

Posts by members, moderators and admins should not be considered medical advice and no guarantee is made against accuracy.